The "Next Man Up" Challenge: Can the 49ers Survive Without Kittle and Warner?
In the high-stakes theater of the NFL playoffs, the term "Next Man Up" is often tossed around as a coaching cliché. But for the San Francisco 49ers heading into today’s Divisional Round clash at Lumen Field, it isn't a cliché—it’s a survival mandate.
The Faithful were hit with a double-dose of devastating news this week: George Kittle (Achilles) and Fred Warner (ankle) are officially out. For a team that relies so heavily on the emotional and tactical leadership of these two All-Pros, their absence creates a void that can’t be filled by just one person. It’s a massive blow to the 49ers' identity on both sides of the ball.
The Aiyuk Shadow: It is impossible to talk about our "depleted" weapons without mentioning the long-term absence of Brandon Aiyuk. Aiyuk hasn't seen the field since October 20, 2024, against the Kansas City Chiefs, where he suffered a catastrophic season-ending torn ACL, MCL, and meniscus. His recovery throughout 2025 was plagued by setbacks and team-related issues that ultimately led to him being placed on the season-ending list for this year as well. With his 2026 guarantees already voided by the front office, we are likely looking at a 49ers roster that has moved on from one of its brightest stars without ever getting him back at 100%.
The Blueprint: Remembering the Week 1 Grinder
To find confidence for today, we only have to look back to September 7, 2025. The 49ers opened the season at this very stadium with a gritty 17-13 win.
That game was a defensive masterclass, and one man stood above the rest: Nick Bosa. While the offense struggled to find a rhythm, Bosa was a heat-seeking missile. The defining moment came with less than a minute remaining. Seattle was at the 49ers' 9-yard line, threatening to steal the game. Bosa bullied right tackle Abraham Lucas into Sam Darnold’s lap, dislodging the ball for a strip-sack fumble that he recovered himself to seal the victory.
With Warner out today, the 49ers need "Defensive Player of the Year" Bosa to be even more dominant to keep the pressure off the backup linebackers and a secondary missing Ji'Ayir Brown.
The Offensive Pivot: Jake Tonges and the TE Legend Gap
Replacing George Kittle is an impossible task. You aren't just replacing a pass-catcher; you’re replacing the best blocking tight end in football. With Kittle sidelined after his Achilles injury last week, the spotlight falls on Jake Tonges.
Tonges is the secret hero of the Seattle rivalry this year. In relief of an injured Kittle during that Week 1 matchup, Tonges hauled in a 4-yard TD pass from a scrambling Brock Purdy with 1:34 left on the clock. It was his first career NFL reception, and it won the game. Since then, he’s been a reliable "red zone" weapon, finishing the 2025 regular season with 5 touchdowns on just 34 catches.
The Perimeter Spark: Demarcus Robinson’s Hot Hand
With Aiyuk out and the passing game needing a vertical threat, Demarcus Robinson has stepped into the light. Robinson is coming off a massive 111-yard performance against the Eagles in the Wild Card round. His ability to win one-on-one matchups is vital because it prevents Seattle from stacking the box against Christian McCaffrey. If Robinson can repeat his Philly performance, he’ll be the "X-factor" that keeps this offense moving.
The Defensive Void: Life Without "The Federation"
On the defensive side, the loss of Fred Warner is arguably even more concerning. Warner is the "brain" of the defense, the man who handles every pre-snap adjustment.
Veteran Eric Kendricks (who recorded 7 solo tackles and a key pass breakup last week) will be the one tasked with wearing the "green dot" and relaying calls. He’ll be supported by Dee Winters and Luke Gifford, but they are facing a Seattle offense that—while Sam Darnold is nursing an oblique injury—still has explosive playmakers like Jaxon Smith-Njigba.
Can Depth Defeat the Odds?
The 49ers enter today as underdogs at Lumen Field, but this roster was built for adversity. From Brock Purdy’s rise to the current "Next Man Up" era, the Faithful know that stars are born in January. Whether Tonges finds the end zone again, the path to the NFC Championship requires every man to play like an All-Pro.
What do you think, Faithful?
Can our depth overcome the loss of Kittle and Warner?
Engagement Question: Who do you trust more to step up today: Jake Tonges filling the Kittle void, or the LB corps trying to replace Fred Warner's defensive genius?
🔴 Join the 49ers Faithful Community
49ers Faithful is a fan-powered San Francisco 49ers blog built by diehard supporters who live and breathe red & gold — not social media algorithms. Our mission is to create a permanent home for the Faithful outside of Facebook.
We’re actively looking for contributors who bring strong opinions, detailed game breakdowns, historical insight, or creative 49ers content that adds value for real fans.
Want to Write About the 49ers?
Comment below or contact us to become a 49ers Faithful contributorFollow 49ers Faithful on Facebook and Instagram.
Click to follow the 49ers Faithful Blog.
🏈 DO-OR-DIE: 49ERS vs SEAHAWKS
This is playoff football. No excuses. No tomorrow. The Faithful ride together.
Who steps up today? Who shocks Seattle? Who earns their January moment?
0 Comments